BG4: “The Hub”

Posted by Bear McCreary on June 7th, 2008

 bg411k.jpg

MORE SPOILERS: The Hub is an exciting episode because it resolves several story lines, and begins new ones as well.   The episode focuses on the battle to destroy the Cylon Resurrection Hub, but also on Laura Roslin, who is among the most complex and interesting characters on the show.  As a result, I was able to write an usually expressive and dynamic score.

The music introduced several new ideas to propel the story forward.  Most importantly, I wrote a new theme to represent the Resurrection Hub:

theme-hub.jpg

The Hub Theme plays throughout the entire battle sequence, an usual choice since it is inherently not energetic action music.  Replacing the expected raging percussion and searing ethnic soloists that typically accompany space battles, this piece is instead introspective and spiritual, because I wanted the music to underscore the incredible importance of the event.  The destruction of the Resurrection Hub completely redefines Cylon existence, and levels the playing field in their war.  The score is underlining these essential truths, while allowing the bullets and spaceships to speak for themselves.

bg411-orch1.jpg

We needed an orchestra to pull this off, and so The Hub was my first opportunity in Season 4 to work with a large ensemble.  It will most certainly not be my last, however. 

bg411-orch2.jpg

The first time I featured orchestral elements on Galactica was during memorable scenes in Kobol’s Last Gleaming, Parts I & II.  The appearance of strings in the context of the otherwise percussion-influenced score made those sequences instantly stand out.  However, over the course of Season 2 and 3, the orchestra appeared more frequently and expanded in size as well.  The ensembles for The Hub and next week’s Revelations were the biggest used on Galactica yet.  The result produces exciting scores, but it also means that the audience has grown accustomed to the orchestral presence.

To keep the sound fresh and interesting, I introduced a new instrument to the Galactica score for the Resurrection Hub battle: the biwa.  This traditional Japenese instrument is a large, 4-string lute that is not played with a pick, but struck with a triangular plectrum.  It has a very distinct, percussive sound, featuring more attack than audible pitch.  And it always makes me think of old samurai movies!  :)

bg411b.jpg

The biwa is first inroduced as the heavy raiders tow the vipers into battle, and it plays throughout the entire attack sequence.  The solitary instrument adds a piercing, aggressive energy to the otherwise lush and elegaic string arrangement.  I’ve had both wonderful and terrible experiences trying to bring a new soloist into the Galactica ensemble, but working with Doctor Osamu Kitajima playing the biwa was a very rewarding experience.  Expect to hear more of this instrument before the series ends.

bg411g.jpg

Scoring the destruction of the hub was the subject of much debate as the producers and I discussed this episode.  Ultimately, we decided that the music should not comment on the vipers, nukes or the decision to fire.  Instead, the score remains mostly silent until the moment of the actual explosion.  Here, a solo erhu and the orchestral strings state the last full statement of the Hub Theme that you will hear in the episode.  The music is not commenting on the explosion as a strategic military victory (as was our approach in The Hand of God when Lee blows up the Tylium factory).  I scored this moment to underline it’s profound impact on the Cylon / Human war.

As the first major battle sequence concludes, Gaius is wounded by an explosion.  As he looks at his wound and grasps the severity of it, a solo duduk states the Hub Theme melody before the score finally takes a break for a minute.

bg411d.jpg

The scene that follows is a shocking revelation as Gaius confesses to Roslin that he was an accomplice to the destruction of humanity.  I felt that this was Baltar’s most important scene in the entire season.  This represented the close of a story arc that goes back to the first season, even the mini-series.  We have always wondered what Roslin would do if she found out the truth about Gaius, and here we get to find out.

I wanted the score for this scene to underscore how far back this storyline goes, so I kept the musical emphasis on older themes.  At the top of the scene, as Gaius first talks of God, the score briefly quotes the Spiritual Baltar Theme:

theme-baltars4.jpg

This progression is most certainly familiar to even casual viewers by now, as it has come to represent Gaius’ new-found religious beliefs.  However, when he says his guilt is gone, the score pauses for a heartbeat for an essential turning point in the scene.

bg411e.jpg

“What was your guilt about?” Roslin asks.  Now, she suspects that she can get the truth out of him.  The score sets two melodic lines in dissonant contrapuntal motion, adding a new layer of tension.  When Gaius confesses, it hits her like a bomb.  Here, the solo duduk returns, stating the Baltar Theme which remains the central thematic element for the rest of the scene:

theme-baltar.jpg

Laura makes the decision to murder Gaius.  As she removes the blood-soaked bandage keeping him alive, an energetic percussion groove adds dread, leading us to the end of the act.  If you dig out the Season One soundtrack CD and cue up Baltar Speaks with Adama (from the episode Six Degrees of Separation), you’ll hear that the percussion comes directly from the end of that track.  It a nice way to tie this scene in with the storyline’s roots in the early episodes of the show, but it was also an opportunity for me to test how far my percussion writing has evolved over the years.  It was fun for me to go back to this groove and re-arrange it, using everything I’ve learned over the past four years.

bg411a.jpg

Space battles aside, The Hub truly centers on Laura Roslin.  The eerie visions of Elosha provided a unique oppportunity to bring back yet another long-dormant theme.  I originally called this simple synth and gamelan motive the Roslin Flashback Theme, because it was written for Season 2’s Epiphanies to underscore Laura’s memories of being on Caprica with President Adar.  However, since it’s been commandeered for new purposes, I’m now calling it the Roslin Vision Theme:

theme-lauravision.jpg

The synth pads osciallate between G major and G minor, while the gamelan ensemble plays a repetitive open 5th pattern, that also touches upon the 6th, but completely ignores the third.  The result is a very emotionally nebulous, dream-like piece that avoids making any sentimental statements.  It worked well in Epiphanies, and is even better in this context, adding to the mystery of the visions without commenting on why Laura is experiencing them.

bg411i.jpg

The Vision Theme plays throughout most of the sequences with Elosha, including the final one as she sits in the hybrid chamber with her.  However, the important Roslin moments are scored with the Roslin and Adama Theme, which plays an essential role in the score:

theme-roslin-adama.jpg

Originally written for Resurrection Ship, Part I & II, this theme has made sporadic appearances since, but never as frequently as during the past 3 or 4 episodes.  Listen for the iconic solo fiddle first as Laura watches Bill at her bedside, mourning her passing.

bg411h1.jpg

It returns again at the episode’s last scene, stated first as Adama looks up to see the baseship has jumped into his field of vision.  Later, as the doors of the raptor open, Laura and Bill finally see each other again.  As a fan of the show, I’ve been waiting four years for these two characters to acknowledge their feelings for one another.  I knew I had to write something special for them.

bg411j.jpg

Fortunately, I’d already written it.  The melody I used is still part of their original theme, however it has literally only been heard once before in the entire series.  On the Season 2 soundtrack album, cue up Roslin and Adama and listen to the final minute.  If the solo fiddle is considered the A Theme, then this uplifting chord progression is the B Theme.  It’s actually my favorite part of that entire piece, and I’ve wanted to bring it back ever since I wrote it.  But, I knew I had to save it for the right moment, a scene that finally progresses their relationship forward.  Without a doubt, this was that scene.

The Hub was a good episode, but next week’s is a very special one to me.  And after that, though it’s hard to believe, we’re off the air for a while.  I’m going to continue to update this blog over the summer, and post Galactica updates as I finish scoring the last ten episodes.  I’ll also post information about several new projects and soundtrack albums I’m doing this year.  So, stick around during the break.  :)

Thanks for reading and enjoy next week’s mid-season finale!

So Say We All,

-Bear

57 Responses to This Blog Entry:

Dude, this one was sweet. This one was very sweet, thats all that needs to be said. Do you use MIDI? if so what for and what software? I use Reason ma’self…

great episode! true artist

I was blown away by the music in this…and hearing that part of the Roslin and Adama theme in the final scene only increased my tear duct leakage. Just re-listening to Roslin and Adama from the S2 soundtrack on my iPod got the tears rolling. That last minute’s my favorite part of that theme too…just when you think the song is over, the tempo accelerates just a little bit, taking you to another plane of unexpected melodic beauty.

Also, I liked hearing Boomer’s theme come back with a slight twist as we get to know this Eight who has accessed Athena’s memories. Thanks so much for sharing your musical insights and inspirations and I can’t wait for next week!

By far my favorite theme you’ve scored for this series is the Roslin/Adama theme. The similarly named track on the Season Two album has played over 5,000 times in my iTunes over the past few years. I loop it when I sleep at night. I have ever second of texture from every instrument on that track blazed in my memory. It is possibly the most beautiful piece of scored music I’ve ever heard. There is something about the transition from the A theme to the B theme that is mesmorizing. The A theme has such a peaceful sorrow to it, and when it gives way to the sense of hope and rightness built into the B theme… gosh… 5,000 times and it still takes my breath away.

There is a reason I’ve had to loop that one track over and over again, however. Because the B theme, that incredible culmination of hope, has never reappeared in the series. That is until last night. Two plus years I’ve waited for that musical moment. I finally got it and it did not dissappoint. Well done, Bear. Well done.

…God help me when Laura dies…

It wasn’t mentioned in the entry, but the moment in which D’Anna “reveals” the Final Cylon was completely sold by the score. Great fake out!

Magnificent episode, and yet again marvelous music that accompagnied it. If it weren’t for your announcement about “the best piece yet” and the choir in next week’s episode, I would have already declared the Hub theme this season’s winning piece. I’m already looking forward to next week!

I continue to be amazed at just how provoked one can get emotionally by music, and the best example of that is the “Roslin and Adama” theme. Kudos for how you went back and integrated it here in “The Hub”.

Sometimes I wish I had the option of isolating the score and going back and re-watching these episodes sans dialogue…..

[...] fact, the music composed by Bear McCreary (read his recap of the episode over here) for that scene was perfect as [...]

Bear, had to register to let you know that your score for The Hub is my favourite of all BSG episodes to date. It was sublime throughout. The Roslin and Adama theme has long been the piece I love best out of all your BSG work (ranking amongst my all time favourites alongside Morricone and Barry). And the rendition of it here was truly moving; its beats in perfect symphony with the emotion of the beautiful reunion scene. Please say that we’ll have more chances to hear this theme in the episodes to come! I too have been waiting 4 years for this relationship to bear fruit and can’t wait to see it blossom further.

Keep up the good work and please consider making the sheet music for this wonderful theme available someday. Thank you for the music.

You’ve out done yourself yet again with this episode! Fantastic job and thanks for bringing back the Roslin and Adama theme! As sad as I am that this series is ending, the soundtrack to season 4 cannot come soon enough!

Oh my gosh! I fall even more in love with your music every episode! My musical knowledge is limited to what I learned playing an instrument in high school, but even I can see how much this music fits in with the series. You have such a talent for drawing out the subtle (and not so subtle) emotional moments within each episode.

I loved the way you scored Baltar’s revelation scene. Your music, tied with Mary and James’ excellent acting, was perfect.

The end scene was another of my favorites. I was first able to recognize the Roslin and Adama theme when he was sitting in the raptor reading and I just couldn’t stop grinning.

Now I can’t wait for next week!

The Roslin and Adama theme – you promised, and you delivered. Indeed, you deliver-issimoed.

“the biwa … always makes me think of old samurai movies!”

There’s a Zatoichi movie in which there’s a character who is a biwa-playing priest. If I remember correctly, he’s also blind.

“I’ve been waiting four years for these two characters to acknowledge their feelings for one another.”

HA! Yes! Me too. I think Adama spoke for all (or at least most) of us when he said, “About time.”

- M. \”/

Glad you explained the reasoning behind the hub destruction. I was kind of expecting a “John Williams blows up the DeathStar” finale… but downplaying this event as a means to a larger end makes sense.

Just wondering… have you ever experimented with 5/4 and 7/8 time signatures (ala Brubeck) to represent the “Final 5″ and “Known 7″ themes? I would love to hear those percussion ensembles grooving on some odd-time beats :-)

gcg2004, I picked up on the Roslin/Adama theme at that same moment. The scene before Adama in the raptor ends with a shot of Roslin sitting alone on the Basestar, when I saw the next shot was the raptor, I was already in tears because I knew what was coming, and sure enough Bear waited all this time for the perfect story telling moment to reintroduce that theme. I love how tender and intimate this incarnation of it is. I hope it isn’t the last we hear of it…

Hi Bear,

I haven’t posted here before, but I read your blog entries every time after watching an episode of Battlestar Galactica. After last nights episode I felt I had to express my thanks to you.
I really don’t know all the nuances that come with making music, what certain variations are called and the differences between c, d or otherwise :(
I do however feel music with all my heart and I have since I was a little kid. My first love was (and still is) John Williams and many that came after that. And not only composers mind you. I am also in love with Siouxsie Sioux the only real queen of punk (the culmination of wich was a private show she gave to present her new cd at the top of the Eiffel Tower in Paris :-).
My favorite artists always know how to get some emotional impact out of me weather it’s with ritmic battledrums or sentimental strings (I really hope you can come to Europe someday to perform because I really would love to see a live show).

Since Battlestar Galactica you have been in my top list. Ever since the eighties no composer came close to the level of artistry that I like so much (the last one was Danny Elfman). I listen to your music almost every day because you make me feel things I didn’t know where there. The subtle theme’s you create are wonderfull and never loose their impact no matter how many times I listen to them. Your music has been a perfect marriage to a perfect tv-show which is one of the best shows on television ever. One of my favorite tracks is “a prelude to war”. The way you integrated the ritmic battledrums with the spiritual emotional parts is pure magic and I listen to that track a lot.

Last night you made me cry again. The new theme when the colonials and the cylon rebels attack the Resurrection Hub is already one of my favorites and I can’t wait for the Season 4 soundtrack (although I fear we have to wait for it for a long time since season 4 completes somewhere in the next year). The theme made me feel space and infinity like only few scores have been able to do before you and it’s a wonderfull feeling. There’s soo much more I would like to say but it’s late and now I want to go to bed with the new theme in my mind.

I want to thank you from the bottom of my heart for the gift you bring us with your music and I hope you will have a long and meaningfull carreer.

sincerely,

Stefan

To break the Roslin and Adama streak that seems to be going on here (though I do agree with the comments and did myself have goosebumps at the end of the episode as well ;-) ) a ‘question’ about the Hub Theme:

Is it just my imagination or is it sort of an alternate version to Gaeta’s Lament from Guess What’s Coming…? I really loved the similarities between the two, making the last line of the Lamtent’s lyrics seem to be reflecting on both the hybrid and D’Anna waking up… very nicely done.

And the change in pace in how the action scenes were scored was a welcome one as far as I am concerned. There’s still plenty of percussion in there, but this way the score just gave the battle the feel of having a larger scope, as well as reminding the audience of how much was at stake for all parties involved.

Cheers on another good one Bear, can’t wait ’till next week :-)

I think you absolutely nailed it with the destruction of the Hub – it could so easily have been a SciFi “ooh, big explosions!” moment, but the score allowed the significance of the event to come through.

There’s so much to say about what your work and that of the musicians does for Battlestar that this might seem to almost miss the point – but the use of music to completely misdirect the audience re: Roslin as a Cylon was absolutely wonderful! It was as though Deanna’s laugh at Roslin’s reaction was really you and the writers laughing at us. Did you mind doing that, or was it nice to take a little break from shaping huge storyline arcs? Unless.. it was one!? :)

Wow.
The Hub Theme is quite possibly the best thing I’ve heard from this show.
The way it moves is swift and elegant, and just amazing.
This is the fourth time I’ve had a “Wow this music is good” experience the first time I’ve watched an episode. The previous three were The Shape of Things to Come, Prelude to War, and Storming New Caprica.
Bear, I know you’ve only released a few samples of songs in the past but please, give us an mp3 taste of this. I can not wait a year and a half to listen to this.

I agree with what everyone has said. This episode was so rewarding in so many ways. Wouldn’t expect anything less from an episode written by Jane Espenson and scored by Bear.

Throughout the episode, I was thinking that unlike so many *lesser* shows and even movies, BSG has always gone above and beyond expectations, and then POW, right between the eyes, a rehashing of Roslin and Adama’s theme.

You’re right, it couldn’t have been used in any other scene than this one.

I continue to marvel at the brilliance of everything about BSG, and this blog really adds an extra, completely enjoyable dimension to my viewing (and provides me with a good excuse to re-watch episodes that just aired-I usually watch an episode as it airs, then read this blog, then watch it again with ears wide open).

Thanks for breaking it all down, Bear, and keep up the sublime work!!!

Bear,
Gosh, you never cease to astound me! I look forward so much to hearing what you’ve done with every new episode and you never fail to disappoint- you always go above and beyond my expectations! You amaze me!
Just wanted to say, about the Russian style choral piece- REALLY?!?!!!! Oh my gosh, you have no idea how elated and simply ESTACTIC that makes me!!!! XD
Also, I remember you said something somewhere about an extra album for all the best unreleased BSG tracks, and I have to say, I think that that would be absolutely fantastic!
I have to say, too, that I hardly ever cry during movies or shows, but I was pretty much sobbing this week, thanks to you and some unbelievable acting performances. Thank you so much, as always!
So Say We All! :) ;)

Absolutely fantastic music for The Hub, as always, Bear. I cannot wait for the Season 4 soundtrack.

The music of Battlestar Galactica just elevates it onto a completely different level from other TV shows. And, for that matter, above many feature films as well. Keep up the great work.

I have a question: I have noticed some Scottish undertones in two of your pieces: Admiral and Commander and The Dance. Being Scottish myself, I was wondering if this was entirely of your construction (having a ‘Mc’ surname) or is someone on the production staff Scottish and asked for it?

bear, stunning work as always.
I agree with konrad. waiting a year or more for the hub theme is going to be brutal.

First of all, I must say that I thoroughly enjoyed the musical score for this week’s episode. I’ve always enjoyed moments where composers juxtapose action sequences with smooth, melodic music (such as season 3’s ‘Violence and Variations’), and I thought that the Hub theme was extremely well done (it’s still playing in my head).

Although I knew that Roslin wasn’t the final Cylon (or at least that she wouldn’t be revealed as such half-way through the season), I second-guessed myself for a brief moment in the scene where Roslin is meeting with D’anna, partially because of the score (I thought I heard chimes briefly, as if harkening back to the ‘Temple of Five’ theme).

I also liked how the serene yet haunting use of the hub theme drew parallels with the score as the resurrection ship was destroyed in season 2’s ‘Resurrection Ship part 2’ (which was more dramatic than bombastic) (and if I’m not mistaken, did both scenes have some basis in the key of G minor?)

Were the similarities between the scores of these two scenes done intentionally?

I know I’m probably suggesting the impossible….but with Sci-Fi’s ludicrous but understandable business decision of placing the back end episodes into 2009, how about producing a CD of the first half of season 4 to placate the fans of your music so they won’t have to wait FOREVER into the middle to end of 2009 for Season 4 music?

I’d pay for it, and I’m sure there are others that would too…..

Pretty please?

Hi Bear,
I’m so glad to tell you how I love your work.Roslin and Adama is my favourite one in all,of course.I’m a musician myself and since I first listened all the scores you’ve recorded,I’ve been trying to play my favorites like r&a,a distant sadness,one year later and a new one Geata’s Lament.It’s challenging but as I said I’m trying.I’m not sure how I can wait until this season’s OST.
Thank you for giving me this opportunity.

Theme B of Roslin and Adama; favorite part of entire season 2. Recognized it instantly – so, so good.

And the eerie music during the battle…

it adds everything.

Love it so hard.
<3

“…producing a CD of the first half of season 4 to placate the fans of your music so they won’t have to wait FOREVER into the middle to end of 2009 for Season 4 music?

I’d pay for it, and I’m sure there are others that would too….”

You _can_ see my hand raised and eagerly waving, can’t you?

Perhaps a mix of music from BSG S4.1 and some from “Razor” and/or stuff omitted from previous seasons’ CDs.

“…the gamelan ensemble…”

Just wondering – did you buy “Golden Rain” for the Ketjak but fall in love with the other side of the record too, like I did?

\”/

Congratulations. You’ve now attained a status in my personal composerverse previously held only by James Newton Howard: that of a composer who can produce music so beguiling and communicative that it can actually musically resolve dangling plot threads and patch up plot holes. (JNH manages to make me believe, while the spell of his music holds, that later entries in M. Night Shyamalan’s oeuvre actually make sense. It’s only after the music ceases that my good sense reasserts itself and protests.)

The Hub destruction music was amazing. The F#-F natural transition struck me as just odd enough that I wondered if the theme were another theme backwards, or if it spelled something, or if it were a row that had been used before, etc. but somehow it makes it seem more genuine, and all the more beautiful, that it wasn’t.

(Also, why was the Hub music playing after Roslin decided to kill Baltar? Not that I actually believe he’s a Cylon, but it did make me sit up straight and stare.)

That said, after I turned off the TV, it hit me that this whole episode, everyone’s talking about how destroying the Hub makes the Cylons mortal for Ever and Ever(!) but, um, didn’t one of the earlier episodes mention that the resurrection ships were for the Cylons too far from the homeworld to resurrect there? And, if they built a Hub once, what’s stopping them from building it again?

Normally these are the sort of things that occur to me immediately and make me grumble at my TV, but nice job with the whole beguiling music thing. *wry*

“…everyone’s talking about how destroying the Hub makes the Cylons mortal for Ever and Ever(!) but, um, didn’t one of the earlier episodes mention that the resurrection ships were for the Cylons too far from the homeworld to resurrect there?”

Consider the possibility that the Hub *is*, in effect, their “homeworld.”

“And, if they built a Hub once, what’s stopping them from building it again?”

That would be great if they weren’t at war – and now a war with three sides. Any survivors of that war might benefit from a rebuilt hub. But any casualties of that war won’t.

- M. \”/

Hey Gang…

As always, I’m thrilled with the intelligent observations and passionate responses from you all. I suspected that the reprise of “Roslin and Adama” would be a big hit, but I honestly never thought it would generate such a huge response.

Daphnis_et_chloe…

I sequence in Digital Performer, but we record and mix in Pro Tools. Reason is a great all-in-one tool, of course, but just not powerful enough as a stand-alone sequencer or recording platform for big projects. By the way, I just answered your other questions in the “Sine Qua Non” comments. Sorry for the long delay…

Romantique…

Boomer’s Theme: I never have room in the blog to go over every musical detail, so I’m glad you mentioned that Boomer’s theme had some really nice appearances in this episode. My favorite was the reveal of the creepy “Boomer Body Chamber.” I wanted to not only make it spooky and scary, but to also add an unsettling sense of emotion and warmth to the lifeless, naked bodies before Helo. Weird stuff!

Vicmackey187 and Phil Edwards…

The fake out when D’Anna “reveals” Laura to be a Cylon was definitely a fun moment. We definitely went for it, trying to sell it as seriously as we could. I love that the moment lasts JUST long enough for the audience to think “You’ve got to be frakkin’ kidding me…” before D’Anna laughs and the tension dissipates. And I wouldn’t say that we were laughing at you guys while working on this moment, but it did make us all smile knowing that collectively every BG fan would gasp in shock for a few seconds. I felt the same way about the moment in the opening minutes of the season when we witness Tigh shoot Adama through the eye. These kinds of moments are very to work on.

bsgfantoo…

The destruction of the Death Star was something we discussed a lot as we were trying to figure out how to score the scene. It’s the gold standard for triumphant outer space explosions! Clearly, we opted to do something different with the music, but it was a conscious decision for sure.
Also, if you’re struggling to find weird time signatures in my music, you’re not listening carefully enough, my friend! :) I write in odd meters all the time. I admit, that none of them are ever numerically significant with regard to “the final five” or “known 7″ or anything like that. But, unusual meters are my favorite trick to employ on this show. Listen to “The Thousandth Landing,” “Mandala in the Clouds,” “Escape from the Farm,” “The Card Game,” “Starbuck Takes on All Eight” or “Black Market” just to name a few. There are some really crazy rhythmic ideas in there. Fun stuff.

RR …

I didn’t deliberately try to connect Gaeta’s Lament with the Hub Theme, but that certainly doesn’t mean that a connection isn’t there. Sometimes these things happen subconsciously.

Also, Gaeta’s Lament WAS quoted again at the top of the episode, during the scene that essentially recapped the end of “Guess What’s Coming to Dinner.”

Spetz…

The introduction of the Scottish elements was my idea. And yes, it was because of my own Scotch Irish heritage. I’m also part Armenian, which is why I wanted to bring the duduk in. These were useful sounds to bring the show anyway, but were also my way of putting a personal thumbprint on the score.

bwinrich…

Yup, the elegaic strings in Resurrection Ship II were also in G minor. Again, I can’t say I did it on purpose, but these things can happen subconsciously. There are many ways that this episode is linked narratively with RS Part II, so it makes sense that I’d be thinking about it.

fanningp…

“how about producing a CD of the first half of season 4 to placate the fans of your music so they won’t have to wait FOREVER into the middle to end of 2009 for Season 4 music?”

I’m thinking about it, but I don’t think it’s going to work out that way. Besides, nothing is going to happen until Sci Fi decides when they’re going to air the back half of the season. I know what you guys are going through though, I want to see the end of the show soon as well!

Jessica…

Couldn’t agree more about the M. Night / J.N. Howard collaborations. And you raise some interesting questions about the Cylons and their resurrection technology. I can’t say too much, but I can tell you that some of these questions will be addressed in the future.

“Jessica…

you raise some interesting questions about the Cylons and their resurrection technology. I can’t say too much, but I can tell you that some of these questions will be addressed in the future.”

Bear, I love these insights to the show (and the music) that you bring to us. I myself thought she brought up very interesting points, too. Glad to know they will be addressed.

Man! An awful lot of comments on “Roslin and Adama”! But I DO remember you saying in the “Sine Qua Non” comments, “You won’t be disappointed all season.”

I hate to “poo-poo” on the parade, but this episode wasn’t all that impressive for me. Not to be the “Simon Cowell” of the forum here, but you’ve done better. Not to be mean, just constructive criticism, and I hope you see it that way.

Still, I have to admit, the music did stand out for me upon subsequent viewing of the episode. And I DID enjoy it more. It’s just that the crescendo “wasn’t really a crescendo”, but I also understand that it wouldn’t have been right for the scene. It would’ve been too powerful in a moment where you needed tenderness and peace.

I’m still Jonesin’ for that crescendo, man! And after next week, we gotta wait? Again!?! Argh!!

Mr McCreary you do an awesome job. I hope that a bit if info about you and the musical process is put on one of the DVDs soon. I thought the music going on when they were plugging the hybrid back into the BaseStar was very fitting for the scene and I hope to hear more of that specific tune.

Keep up the good work and God bless!

Thanks for the response, Bear. As long as you’re considering the “idea” of a 4.0 CD release, that’s all we could ask for….

It would definitely make the wait for the back-half of the season go alot quicker (and better)….

Thanks for staying so engaged and responsive with the fans, I know I really appreciate it….

So no season 4 soundtrack for quite some time……understandable. But perhaps just the Hub theme on Itunes or something like that. I’d pay for it. That music has been haunting me since I saw the last episode and I don’t mind it one bit.

By the way, have you thought about doing concert suites for some of the most memorable themes on the show. Something like John Williams does with just about every score he has done for either George Lucas or Steven Spielberg.
I know the Hub theme would become a very impressive Concert Suite (it has already been playing in my head :-)

All the best………

Okay, okay. I give.

I may have been a little too hasty in my first post. After watching “Hub” a few more times, the music grew on me. The Hub theme reminds me a bit of parts of “Violence and Variations”, one of my favorites. I still feel it’s a bit incomplete, though. But I’m sure Bear will expand on it in forthcoming episodes.

I think my commentary reflected more on the episode itself rather than the music. It’s all “Laura, Laura, Laura.” There’s a few things that I didn’t like about the episode, but too much for me to elaborate on here. (Besides, this blog is about the music.) I’m just getting drained on the “Laura-centric” part of the show. Too much build-up, and not enough action. I thought Lucy Lawless was great, though. (WAY better than Xena!) Glad she’s back. And I like this new Eight with Athena’s memories.

Well, I’m sure we’ll hit some big moments (and melodies and crescendos) this Friday, being the last of the first half of the season and all.

Looking forward to it!

Ok, just when I thought no piece could come close to Roslin and Adama’s theme for me…you go and bring The Hub theme…I had to rewatch the frakking episode over cos the first time I wasn’t watching the fight I was listening to that amazing score. Simply beautiful, spinetingly good! THEN you go and totally blow me away with a rehash of the R+A (we can call it LOVE now right??) Theme. Thanks you had me blubbing like a baby at that final scene from when the baseship jumps back to the TAHNK GODS ABOUT FRAKKIN TIME love declaration. We will get to hear the guitary bit though soon right?? Thanks again for astounding me week after week! Im sorry my responses aren’t more musically critiquing but aside from the flute I don’t really play much else Jessox

Music was just truly amazing! I cannot wait for another release of music on Audio CD. Thank you very much Bear for keeping up this outstanding work which makes my life happier :-)

Hello,

First off, big fan of the BSG soundtracks, and listen to them daily, both at home and at work. But there’s something I’ve been wondering for a very long time, so I’d hope you could settle a little bet for me.

The Roslin and adama theme (found on S02 soundtrack and heard again now in the hub, amongst other parts of the series), was it based on or inspired by “Leave no man behind” theme from Black hawk down (or the piece that, “Leave no man behind” was itself inspired by)? The similarities are there, tho somewhat different in arrangement, and well, I was hoping you could settle this little bet I have with a friend.

Also, on the same topic, am I imagining it or was minstrel bos played in S01, or the pilot (I know you didn’t score the pilot, but maybe you could give an answer to that aswell).

What other pieces have been incorporated into the BSG soundtrack, or a refrase: What music has been your inspiration for the BSG soundtrack?

The All along the watchtower remake was really awesom aswell, can we expect more lyrical music from you, be it in the show or separate from the show?

Best Regards
Pouria

Okay, so this is a little off topic, but I was just watching the trailer for The Other Boleyn Girl and I swear I heard Bear’s music at the very end of the trailer (it’s in the last five seconds of the trailer as the titles come up). The music was the beginning riff from Two Funerals. Is that your music Bear or did they just totally hack your theme from that song?

Brilliant, brilliant, I loved this piece of action music. Took me back to Ressurection Part II while having a flare all it’s on. And I completely understand that you can’t write an amazing string piece for any old scene but when the scene came up you certainly didnt dissappoint. Just when I thought the percussion heavy pieces were all we were going to hear over the action (fantastic as they are), you definetly took it to a different place. Now, my only complaint is I have to wait till Tuesday to hear what you’ve got next for us (this is the problem of living in Ireland). Dieing to hear that choir piece.
I liked the restrained decision to have minimal music in the early scenes of the episode, very wise, gave the whole thing a sense of anticipation, while underlining the fact that the episode was really about Roslin. It was a very touching last scene, between Roslin and Adama.

Mr. McCreary,
I just wanted to commend you for not only being a phenomenal composer, but being so loyal and responsive to all your fans. Its truly awesome that you take time out of your schedule to make these detailed blog posts and most of all to acknowledge fan responses and answer people’s questions. I know I’m not the first fan to do this, but I just wanted to express how much I do appreciate what you do both in music and here on this blog. I am looking so forward to what you have in store for us in the future!

“Okay, so this is a little off topic, but I was just watching the trailer for The Other Boleyn Girl and I swear I heard Bear’s music at the very end of the trailer (it’s in the last five seconds of the trailer as the titles come up). The music was the beginning riff from Two Funerals. Is that your music Bear or did they just totally hack your theme from that song?”

Hoot, that is most definitly Bear’s music that is at the end of the trailer. My proof is here: http://www.soundtrack.net/movies/database/?id=19387

Hey Bear. I’m loving the music. Unfortunatly I’ve not got the sci-fi channel though and have been buying the DVDs but I’ve been reading some of other people comments (trying to avoid the spoilers and forget the ones I do accidentally read!) and while the release of a season 4.0 soundtrack sounds amazing I’m trying not to get too excited as you said it might not happen.

On the other hand I’m very excited about the Eureka season 2 soundtrack this summer and wondered whether we can expect the Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles soundtrack before the end of Battlestar Galactica Season 4 cos I can’t wait for either but with season 1 of The Sarah Connor Chronicles over it seems more likely to have the first release of the 2. Can I start to get excited about it or is it still a way off from release?

Hi Bear,

I see you have a picture of yourself directing the orchestra. And, while the orchestra is right in front of you, you have headphones on. Why is that? I would assume you’re listening to them…so…if they are right there…what’s the need for headphones? Or are the headphones to protect your ears so you don’t hear the orchestra?

And why is there a mike in front of you (and not the orchestra). You don’t look to be singing…

Thanks

Grnidone-

I bet the headphones are probably to hear a click track so that he can make sure tempos match what they need to be to sync to the picture. (Or to hear other layered tracks along with what’s being recorded… like for instance the mid season finale, if i’m not mistaken, the strings, brass, and choir were all recorded on separate passes) And the microphone is perhaps so he can speak to the engineers in the monitoring rooom?

During the last week, i encountered a violonist. I was fascinated by this instrument and then, when he have finished to play, i played on my computer “roslin and adama”, the violonist was impressed, after, he plays only for me a gaelic music, based on this theme…
You know, for me, you’re like a god of music, because of you, i want to play again music with flute and recorder!!
I think you’re mad!!! I love all musics in this episode, really, it’s an amazing job…

Thank you!!

Airmanjoe… “I thought the music going on when they were plugging the hybrid back into the BaseStar was very fitting for the scene and I hope to hear more of that specific tune.”

… that was a recap of Gaeta’s Lament, from “Guess What’s Coming to Dinner,” to help connect this story to that episode. It’s a cool tune.

Darth Neo… I absolutely intend to assemble a “Galactica” Concert Suite once the series ends.

Hoot… Yup, that’s my music from the BG Season One Soundtrack at the end of the Other Bolelyn Girl soundtrack. It was a pleasant surprise when I saw it.

Grnidone…

Thanks for asking about the headphones. :)

And musicpaladin2007 is absolutely correct. The headphones are so that everyone in the room (myself, and all the musicians) can hear the click track and hear all the tracks that aren’t being recorded live (for example, the taiko drums, etc). And the mic in front of me is so that I can talk to the engineers in the booth without having to shout.

VirtuaproD…

Tell your violinist friend that the BG violinist’s name is Paul Cartwright. I’ve written a blog entry specifically about him which your friend will enjoy.

Okay, so a slightly random question I’ve had for a while now is made slightly more relevant with the last couple of weeks…

…what are the odds of ever hearing the “Roslin And Adama” theme arranged with some sort of vocal track? I know, I know, it sounds kind of wacky, but I’ve been making up words and singing the melody to myself in the car for weeks now, and after binge-listening to earlier tracks like “A Distant Sadness,” and listening to the AMAZING choral work you did with the oratorio in “Revelations”…I gotta say, I’ve been thinking way too much about how amazing certain familiar themes on this show might sound with vocals.

I just have this twisted aural “vision,” as it were, of Raya’s hauntingly appropriate voice carrying the solo string portion of the “Roslin And Adama” theme. But then, I could probably listen to endless reimaginings of that theme, so.

*Spends some time learning about what a Click Track is in Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Click_track), then spends more time learning that a ‘Metronome’ is one of those tick tock thingys found on pianos*

*Wastes a few brain cells wondering how Bear doesn’t go crazy listening to that constant sound*

*All in all, fascinated by the idea of a click track*

I am curious to know, however, if you’ve got a long musical piece (5 minutes or more) and it changes time several times in the piece…how does one actually *make* the click track? Is it something you can just program into a computer and say “I need 20 sets of this time followed by 10 sets of this other time and 15 sets of the first time…?”

And how do you match the ‘non live’ taikos (for example) with the click track in the proper place that the taikos need to be?

I haven’t posted here before, but let me say that I think BSG may have the best TV score… ever? Given that, the gravity of what I mean when I say that “The Hub” had the best music in BSG should be apparent. I think I have had the Hub’s theme stuck in my head almost continuously since the episode first aired; it is perhaps the most haunting theme I’ve heard in any music, and I hope you have the chance to bring it back again in future episodes (though I realized it may have been specific to something we will not see again.) I thought I liked the first 3 BSG soundtracks, but I cannot *wait* for the fourth now!

The music in the Hub space battle turned it from “just another” (typically amazing!) BSG space battle into something more akin to a lost epic battle from Kubrick’s 2001; the contrast of the intense-action space fight and the relatively peaceful music was absolutely perfect and demonstrated the gravity of what was happening flawlessly.

Keep it up!

Grnidone…

“how does one actually *make* the click track?”

Sorry, I know you asked this months ago. In the off chance you come back here to check it out…

I compose in sequencing software that allows me to program MIDI tracks, adjust tempo, place markers, etc. Since the tempo is dictated by my programming in the sequencing software, I export a MIDI file to Steve Kaplan my co-producer and mixing engineer. From there, he can easily generate a click track (based on my tempo information) that all the musicians can hear as we record. I can also slow the music down, speed it up… do anything with it I want… and the click will always match my music exactly.

Alyssa… (apologies again on the extremely long-delayed answer)…

“…what are the odds of ever hearing the “Roslin And Adama” theme arranged with some sort of vocal track?”

So funny you’d ask, because we sort of already did it. Raya incorporated the Roslin and Adama theme into an original pop composition that we played at the first “Music of Battlestar Galactica” concert in 2006.

We never did a studio recording of it, so there isn’t really a recording of it. And technically, it wasn’t just lyrics set to the theme, but the theme incorporated into a brand-new piece of music. Raya re-arranged it and re-harmonized it. It was really a lot of fun….

Darth Neo —-

YOU SPOKE FOR ME in clearer terms than i know, in any one of ten or more languages i work with here and at places of work/writing…

Wow. I love this show beyond any measure of normality…

But it is what I am. That is, it slays asshats and idiocy… with grace, like Whedonesque heroes and slayers that date … vamps.

Bear-

Had a composition-process related question for ya. I know you mentioned in your entry for Revelations that it changed the way you approach the rest of the series compositionally. I know you said that you can’t say too much about that at this point, but did this in turn affect the way you scored “The Hub”? (since I know you mentioned you actually scored that AFTER Revelations)

Please please add the Roslin and Adama Theme from the last scene. I love it!

Something to Say?

You must be logged in to post a comment.